Heat pump or air conditioning for heating? A detailed comparison and decision guide

Hőszivattyú vagy klíma fűtésre? Részletes összehasonlítás és döntési útmutató

Heat pump or air conditioning? If you are looking for a new heating system, the choice between the two technologies depends primarily on the characteristics of the property, the budget available and your comfort requirements. Air-conditioning-based heating is generally cheaper to install, whilst an air-to-water heat pump can form the basis of a complete central heating system, which can even provide domestic hot water.

Let’s take a look at which solution is best in which situation, how much it costs to run them, and what you should bear in mind before making your choice!

An air-conditioning system is also a heat pump – so what’s the difference?

A heat pump air conditioner is, in fact, an air-to-air heat pump. It extracts heat from the outside air, which the indoor unit then transfers directly to the air in the room. The system responds quickly, and the same unit can also be used for cooling in summer.

In contrast, an air-to-water heat pump transfers the extracted heat to a water-based heating system. The hot water heats the building via underfloor heating, radiators or fan coils. If designed appropriately, it can also be used to produce domestic hot water.

The two technologies therefore operate on a similar principle; the main difference lies in the way heat is dissipated. For details of how they work, see the What is a heat pump air conditioner or how does an air conditioner heat in winter? You can read more about this in our article entitled […].

Heat pumps vs. air conditioning: the key differences

Criterion Heating and air conditioning Air-to-water heat pump
Capital expenditure Generally lower Generally higher
Installation Simpler, quicker More complex mechanical engineering design
Heat dissipation Direct air heating Underfloor heating, radiators, fan coils
Heating comfort Rapid heating, with air circulation Even and draught-free thanks to underfloor heating
Room-by-room control Per indoor unit With appropriate zone control
Cooling Basic function This can be resolved with the right system
Domestic hot water Special equipment is required The system can be used to produce
Typical uses Flats, small houses, supplementary heating Complete heating systems for detached houses

How much does heating cost with air conditioning and a heat pump?

Investment costs

The main financial advantage of air-conditioning for heating is the lower initial investment. Installing a single split-system air conditioner is considerably cheaper than installing an air-to-water heat pump system. However, larger properties may require several indoor units, which increases the costs.

In the case of an air-to-water heat pump, in addition to the unit itself, you must also factor in the pipework, heat emitters, control systems and, where applicable, the hot water storage tank. In a newly built house, however, the installation of a central heating system may form part of the initial investment, so the basis for comparing costs is different.

Operating costs

We cannot state that an air-to-water heat pump always consumes less electricity than a heating air conditioner. The efficiency of both technologies is determined by the technical specifications of the unit and the operating conditions. One important indicator for comparison is the SCOP, or seasonal coefficient of performance. A SCOP value of 4 means that, under standard test conditions, the unit provides an average of 4 kWh of heat for every 1 kWh of electricity consumed during the heating season.

The heating and cooling system can also operate at a favourable efficiency, whilst the efficiency of an air-to-water heat pump can be particularly good when used with underfloor heating that operates at a low flow temperature. Efficiency typically decreases when used with radiators that require a high water temperature.

The discounted H tariff is available for both technologies, provided that the equipment and the electrical installation meet the relevant criteria.

If you currently use a gas boiler for heating and want to reduce your running costs, read the Air conditioning vs gas heating running costs: should we switch to air conditioning? our comparison entitled ….

Heating comfort: which one provides a more pleasant feeling of warmth?

The air-conditioning heats the room quickly, which is particularly advantageous in properties used only occasionally. At the same time, it circulates the air using a fan, so it involves air movement and generates a certain amount of noise. The positioning of the indoor unit is therefore also important in terms of comfort.

An air-to-water heat pump, when combined with underfloor heating, ensures even heat distribution and draught-free heating. Underfloor heating, however, reacts more slowly to changes in temperature. With radiator or fan-coil systems, the sensation of warmth is different: comfort is therefore determined not by the heat pump itself, but by the associated heat emitters.

Hőszivattyú vagy klíma fűtésre? Részletes összehasonlítás és döntési útmutató

Which one works better in winter, when it’s really cold?

Both heating air-conditioning units and air-to-water heat pumps are capable of operating at temperatures below freezing. Some air-conditioning units optimised for heating can operate reliably even at outdoor temperatures as low as –20 or –25 °C, but this does not mean that they maintain the same performance and efficiency in such cold conditions.

The same applies to air-to-water heat pumps: as the outside temperature falls, efficiency generally decreases, whilst the building’s heating requirements increase.

When choosing a unit, it is not enough to consider the rated output; you must also check whether the unit is capable of providing the required heating output even at winter temperatures.

Heat pump or air conditioning: which is the best choice for which property?

The choice between the two technologies is significantly influenced by whether the property in question is a new-build or an existing property.

In a newly built detached house The combination of an air-to-water heat pump and underfloor heating is often the obvious choice. The entire mechanical system can be designed in a coordinated manner, and domestic hot water can also be provided. In smaller, well-insulated houses, however, air-conditioning-based heating can also be a cost-effective alternative.

In an existing detached house with radiators Firstly, the suitability of the radiators must be checked. If the radiators are only capable of heating the building at a high flow temperature, the switch to a heat pump may also require the replacement of radiators or other modernisation work. We discuss this in detail in the Which radiators are suitable for heat pumps? in our article entitled ….

In flats and smaller properties, air-conditioning-based heating is often the simpler and more cost-effective option. There is no need to install a water-based heating system, but you do need to consider the floor plan: a single indoor unit may not necessarily be able to heat several separate rooms evenly.

In poorly insulated buildings, it is worth assessing heat loss before replacing the heating system. Improving the insulation reduces the heating output required and subsequent running costs.

The various options are set out in the Heating systems for a family house - what to choose? We also compare them in our guide entitled […].

Decision guide: which system offers better value?

The table below will help you determine which technology is worth looking into first.

Life situation Recommended initial solution Main reason
A small flat, without central heating Heating and air conditioning Lower investment costs
Newly built house with underfloor heating Air-to-water heat pump Integrated heating and hot water supply
Upgrading an existing heating system Heating and air conditioning Simple, room-by-room installation
Modernisation of a detached house with radiators Customised technical survey Radiators and heating requirements are crucial
Heating for several separate rooms Both are to be examined The floor plan and heat distribution are key factors
Heating and domestic hot water in a single system Air-to-water heat pump A comprehensive building services solution

The two technologies are not mutually exclusive. For example, split-system air-conditioners can be installed alongside underfloor heating powered by an air-to-water heat pump; these provide cooling in summer and rapid supplementary heating during the transitional periods.

Summary: heat pump or air conditioning?

If the aim is a smaller investment, simple installation and rapid heating, an air-conditioning system may be the better option. However, if you wish to provide heating and domestic hot water for an entire detached house, particularly with underfloor heating, an air-to-water heat pump may offer a better solution.

Not sure which system is right for your property? SMARTAIR’s experts can help you choose the right heating solution based on the technical specifications and your requirements. Ask for a personalised quote!